Harry Reid announced an opt out clause for the public option.

As the debate over health care reform rages on several powerful politicians are crafting a bill that will ultimately be voted on the Senate floor.  Today Harry Reid unveiled an interesting spin allowing for states to opt out from the public option.  As you remember the version of the bill championed by Max Baucus did not contain a public option, however it is now being combined with a version from the HELP committee and that one did contain the public option.  Because of the relative unpopularity among senators and the public alike, Reid crafted a compromise that would theoretically be appealing. 

What is especially odd about this move is the manner in which Olympia Snowe was "suckered" into voting for the version from the Finance committee while issuing a warning that she will not support a public option.  Therefore it certainly appears that promises were made in order to get some version out of the finance committee.  However Reid's proposals raises serious questions.

How do states opt out, if federal taxes are levied across the board?  Citizens will not be too keen on opting out of a program they are paying for. 
Who decides the opting out process?  Governor, state legislature or even a ballot initiative could all be viable options and will add to the confusion. 
What about the individual mandate?  If the public option is optional why is the mandate to purchase insurance not optional?  Perplexing at best.

This looks like a strategy to get the public option in the final bill in a subversive manner to appeal to the most left-wing base of the Democrat party.  Obama has gone back and forth on the public option, but beyond all the words and facades he secretly wants a public option and even a single payer option as he once professed on the campaign trail. 

This is not health reform, this is a few people toying around with one of the most crucial aspects of our lives and it is appalling to see how many games the powerful elite are willing to play in order to acquire more power. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The 2009 credit boom is coming to an end.

Image
The credit expansion boom of 2009 will eventually go down as yet another period of credit expansion promoted by the Fed that will have lead to another predictable bust.   Today, it will be interesting to examine how the various levels of production are behaving under years and years of artificial interest rate suppression.  It will also be helpful to look at charts and graphs examining the business cycle theory and the impact of time preference as taught by Mises. For starters, those new to the concept - a very brief paraphrasing of the general idea. Under a healthy functioning market people's consumer patterns impact their savings.  More consumption equals less saving and less consumption more saving.  In order to progress the society must save such that it can make investments in machinery, equipment, technology, etc if it hopes to increase the capacity of production.   Sure ,you can harvest 10 coconuts a day, consume them by night and repeat the process...
Read more

What is wrong with this country?

I was browsing the latest IBD poll and it finally struck me. I had this idea brewing for the past few weeks now and this particular poll hit a nerve. What jumped out was the age group and who they are likely voting for. Obama / McCain 18-24: 74% 21% The rest of the age groups are more or less even with ages 65+ leaning more for McCain. Those folks should probably avoid leaning - hazardous to their health. Now, if you are a member of this group and are part of the 74% you are probably feeling good about yourself. If you are in the 21% then you are probably used to feeling desperate and angry that your peers ostracize you as if you were the next coming of the bubonic plague. But this number is very telling. Showing to us that a large group of freshly minted liberals, on average still in college, is in a very good position to influence these elections. Enthralled by the concept of "what they want the world to be" and their utopian ideals they hammer their message to anyone willi...
Read more

Cult of Personality Watch: Obama day

I suspect I might have to make a regular piece about this, given the nature of this presidency. Today's CoP moment, brought to you by http://cjonline.com/stories/110908/loc_353922770.shtml Planning under way for Obama holiday The Capital-Journal Published Sunday, November 09, 2008 Plans are being made to promote a national holiday for Barack Obama, who will become the nation's 44th president when he takes the oath of office Jan. 20. "Yes We Can" planning rallies will be at 7 a.m. and 7 p.m. every Tuesday at the downtown McDonald's restaurant, 1100 Kansas Ave., until Jan. 13. The goals are to secure a national holiday in Obama's honor, to organize celebrations around his inauguration and to celebrate the 200th birthday of President Abraham Lincoln, who was born on Feb. 12 1809. At 7:30 a.m. on Inauguration Day, Obama Cake will be served at the downtown McDonald's, and a celebration is scheduled for 8 p.m. to midnight Jan. 20 at the Ramada Hotel and Conventi...
Read more